10 Questions The Harry Potter Movies Don’t Answer But The Books Do

The Harry Potter films had the daunting process of becoming many storylines, subplots, and side-characters into feature-length options whereas nonetheless growing the principle characters and the ever-growing stakes, so some stuff was omitted. Naturally, it is anticipated that any film adaptation of a literary work will omit particulars to translate books into movies, however Harry Potter does a very disappointing job. The tone within the latter half of the sequence is off, many vital characters by no means get their due, and fairly a number of obvious questions stay unanswered, regardless of the franchise comprising eight whole movies.

Not solely did Harry Potter cut most of Remus Lupin’s storyline, however the movies also ruined Mad-Eye Moody, each of whom are vital characters within the books, particularly Lupin. Whereas a number of the omitted particulars from the books straight hamper the circulate of logic and plot improvement, there are some that might have enriched the viewing expertise. From the existence of Peeves the Poltergeist to the vital cut scene of Gilderoy Lockhart at St. Mungo’s Hospital, the variety of particulars omitted from the films will all the time be a degree of competition for readers of the books.

10

How The Demise Eaters Discovered The Trio In The Espresso Store

Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows – Half 1

Early on within the first a part of the two-part epic conclusion to the Harry Potter movie franchise, Harry, Ron, and Hermione must shortly escape from Invoice and Fleur’s wedding ceremony after Demise Eaters crash the celebration. They get away and make a cease at a café on Tottenham Court docket Highway to take inventory of their circumstances. Nevertheless, whereas there, the Demise Eaters ultimately discover them and assault them mid-conversation, and so they have a confrontation contained in the café.

Associated

Harry Potter: 10 Worst Movie Plot Holes That Were Explained In The Books (According To Reddit)

The Harry Potter films are fairly nice, however they did have a number of plot holes. As a rule, these holes had been handled within the books.

Whereas this scene highlights the Demise Eaters’ attain and helps set up how excessive the stakes are for the trio, it would not make sense that they had been found in a random café. The books present the right clarification – Voldemort’s title has a powerful taboo spell on it, so the Demise Eaters instantly know the placement of anybody who utters the title. For this reason they’re by no means tracked down till the top of the film – a obvious plot gap within the movie that appears like plot armor with out this element.

9

How Fred And George Funded Their Store

Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince

One of many much less burning questions that viewers may need after watching Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince issues Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes. The great joke store opened by the Weasley twins, Fred and George, is the placement for top-of-the-line scenes within the films. It’s a transient go to to the store, however that’s all it takes to go away a long-lasting impression. An omitted element from the books explains how they opened the store, and additional establishes the deep bond of affection and friendship the twins share with Harry all through the sequence.

Fred and George famously did not end their education, leaving Hogwarts after an elaborate prank (the one within the books differs from the one within the films), and the Weasleys are proven to be financially struggling since their first look. It is clear they’d by no means get a mortgage due to their popularity, so how do they fund such a big store? The reply, as revealed within the books, is that Harry, after successful the Triwizard Match in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, won a cash prize (a element the movie omitted), and gave all his winnings to the twins.

8

Why Dementors Attacked Harry At Little Whinging

Harry Potter And The Order of the Phoenix

Amongst different memorable characters, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix launched viewers to the despicable character of Dolores Umbridge. A strict trainer despatched by the Ministry to manage the college’s training, who ultimately takes on the position of Headmistress in Dumbledore’s absence, has damage extra college students than any trainer ought to. Nevertheless, whereas she ruins their faculty lives together with her archaic ideas and virtually endangers college students together with her lack of sensible pondering, the films miss the worst factor she did.

Some of the memorable Harry Potter film openings is the scene the place dementors attack Dudley Dursley and Harry Potter at Little Whinging. Dementors aren’t speculated to lurk in locations the place there could also be many muggles residing, however they appeared out Harry at his residence, forcing him to do magic exterior faculty to fend them off. The books ultimately clarify that it was Umbridge who had despatched dementors after him, revealing simply how irrational and hateful she was, of somebody she hadn’t even met but!

7

How Rita Skeeter Discovered Out Everybody’s Secrets and techniques

Harry Potter And The Goblet of Hearth

Whereas he had all the time been well-known for being the one recognized survivor of an assault by the Darkish Lord, Harry Potter had lived a life shielded from the standard penalties of fame till Harry Potter and the Goblet of Hearth. Since nobody knew he lived with the Dursleys exterior a really unique circle of individuals, and Hogwarts did not permit strangers into their grounds, he was in a position to escape the limelight till the Triwizard Match. Because the youngest competitor whose title should not have been chosen, he was much more within the highlight.

That is when one of many best minor Harry Potter characters, Rita Skeeter, entered his life and began publishing private tales and photos, twisting his phrases and spreading rumors like several paparazzi. Nevertheless, she was extremely efficient at her job, higher than one will be merely with analysis and connections. Her complicated stage of competence is straight away defined when one takes under consideration that she is an animagus and might flip right into a beetle. She makes her means into rooms and listens to personal conversations, violating each boundary, however the movies miss this vital element about her.

6

Why Snape Is The Half-Blood Prince

Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince

One of many coolest units in the entire Harry Potter Wizarding World is the Pensieve. It permits somebody to look at one other individual’s recollections like a fly on the wall. Its most compelling use comes within the ultimate film of the franchise, the place it reveals Snape’s actually tragic backstory as an everlasting protector of Harry regardless of his habits. Nevertheless, that is additionally as a result of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince is missing Pensieve memory scenes. That is not all of the film leaves out, although, as probably the most iconic twist within the movie can be underdeveloped.

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince has one of many strongest film endings with its delicate revelation about Snape. When he’s hit with a spell from the Half-Blood Prince’s e book, he retorts by saying Harry should not use his spells in opposition to him. Whereas this jaw-dropping second efficiently surprises viewers, together with particulars from the e book would have added extra of a whodunnit tone to the thriller of the author’s identification. The books revealed that Snape’s father was a Muggle, explaining his adopted identification.

5

How Barty Crouch Jr. Escaped From Azkaban

Harry Potter And The Goblet of Hearth

Some of the stunning revelations in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Hearth is the second the viewers learns Mad-Eye Moody’s true identification. Not solely has Barty Crouch Jr. been impersonating the well-known auror with polyjuice potion for an entire 12 months, however he’s additionally one in every of Voldemort’s most trusted Demise Eaters. Nevertheless, the earlier movie confirmed us how strict the Wizarding World is about prisoners, particularly these from Azkaban, so the truth that there have been no posters and no person knew he had escaped is a complicated plot gap within the film.

Associated

One Thing About Barty Crouch Jr In Harry Potter Has Always Bothered Me (But I Finally Get It)

Barty Crouch Jr’s story was one thing of a contradiction, however a line within the Harry Potter books explains why he made the tragic decisions that he did.

The books fully clarify the occasions, although. Barty Crouch Jr. was changed by his dying mom at Azkaban, with out anybody noticing, and in consequence, his father had him saved underneath home arrest. He was guarded by the Crouch household’s home elf, Winky (whose existence is omitted from the movies), made to stay coated by an Invisibility Cloak, and continuously underneath the affect of an Imperius Curse. His father took him to the Quidditch World Cup after 12 years of home arrest, however he used the video games as a distraction to flee and put Voldemort’s plan into motion.

4

The place Voldemort Discovered His Horcruxes

Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince

The first quest for the golden trio in Harry Potter is destroying the horcruxes or soul remnants of Voldemort earlier than they confront him head on, so he dies this time. Unknowingly, Harry has destroyed one in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and techniques, but it surely’s not till Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince that he discovers what a horcrux is and the way one makes it. Killing an individual will permit somebody to tear their soul into two and retailer a remnant in an object of significance to allow them to turn out to be immortal till that object is destroyed.

Whereas it’s revealed within the movie that Voldemort made seven horcruxes, it is not defined the place he discovered the objects and the way he made the horcruxes. The books give us detailed background on every of the six horcruxes he deliberately made, and depart the seventh a thriller. By watching recollections within the Pensieve and conversing with Dumbledore, Harry learns about Voldemort’s numerous horcruxes, and this element would have added to the lore of one of the underdeveloped and underwhelming film villains of all time, and helped him really feel just a little extra compelling.

3

The place The Two-Approach Mirror Comes From

Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows – Half 1

Some of the harrowing scenes in all the Harry Potter movie franchise is Hermione’s torture by the hands of Bellatrix Lestrange on the Malfoy Manor in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Half 1. It culminates within the loss of life of Dobby the Home Elf, an vital franchise character who wasn’t there in the first movie. Nevertheless, earlier than he dies, Dobby rescues the trio from Malfoy Manor, because of a shard of glass Harry carries that he’s positive someway hyperlinks to Dumbledore. It’s revealed that Aberforth, Albus’s brother, is the one who helped them out.

To those that have not learn the books, each this two-way mirror and the character of Aberforth Dumbledore should come as complicated inclusions. Within the Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix e book, Sirius presents Harry a two-way mirror, saying he and his father used to make use of the same machine to be in contact as soon as. Nevertheless, Harry forgets about it till after Sirius’ loss of life, and breaks the mirror in a second of frustration and retains one of many shards. Aberforth purchased the remainder of the mirror from Mundungus Fletcher, and that is how he can talk with Harry utilizing it.

2

How Harry Survives The Killing Curse

Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows – Half 2

A few of the particulars that the Harry Potter films miss from the books not solely make the supply materials appear lazily written, however additionally they give Harry rather more plot armor than he initially had. Among the many most complicated moments of him simply surviving conditions he should not, is, after all, the enduring scene from Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Half 2, when Voldemort hits him with a Killing Curse. Harry’s supposed loss of life had a near-perfect buildup, resulting in an epic, emotionally charged second, however he bizarrely simply comes again to life afterward.

The books supply a well-developed reasoning behind Harry’s survival, incorporating a number of explanations for the inexplicable phenomenon. Firstly, it’s revealed that Harry had turn out to be a horcrux of Voldemort when he killed Lily Potter and her protecting protect made the Killing Curse rebound off Harry. The killing curse solely killed the a part of Harry that was Voldemort’s horcrux, leaving Potter alive. Secondly, the Elder Wand technically belonged to Harry, and Voldemort’s try to kill him utilizing it saved him. Thirdly, Lily’s protecting allure helped as a result of Voldemort has carried Harry’s blood inside him since Harry Potter and The Goblet of Hearth.

1

Who The Actual Marauders Are

Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban

Alfonso Cuarón’s Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is probably the most beloved movie in all the franchise for a lot of, and amongst different components, one in every of its most noteworthy introductions to followers of the Wizarding World is the Marauders’ Map. Fred and George give Harry a map of Hogwarts that tracks the areas of everybody within the faculty and on the grounds. It is called the Marauders’ Map, created by Messrs. Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, and Prongs, who confer with themselves because the Marauders on the map.

Associated

The History Of The Marauder’s Map Explained: Why It Was Created, By Who & More Questions Answered

The Marauder’s Map’s historical past was omitted of the Harry Potter films, however the books and Wizarding World web site higher clarify the difficult doc.

It’s revealed in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban that Lupin is a werewolf, and each Peter Pettigrew and Sirius Black are animagi who can remodel right into a rat and a canine, respectively. We additionally be taught that Harry’s patronus is a stag, identical to his father. Nevertheless, the e book really revealed that James Potter was additionally an animagus who may flip right into a stag, and Remus, Peter, Sirius, and James are Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, and Prongs, respectively, making the 4 of them the Marauders!

Solid

Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson, Rupert Grint, Tom Felton, Alan Rickman, Matthew Lewis, Bonnie Wright, Evanna Lynch, Maggie Smith, Michael Gambon, Richard Harris, Ralph Fiennes, Helena Bonham Carter, Alfred Enoch, Harry Melling, Gary Oldman, Robert Pattinson, Warwick Davis, Oliver Phelps, James Phelps, David Bradley, David Thewlis, Katie Leung, Jason Isaacs, Imelda Staunton, David Tennant, Jamie Campbell Bower, Timothy Spall, Robbie Coltrane, Eddie Redmayne, Jude Law, Katherine Waterston, Ezra Miller, Dan Fogler, Alison Sudol, Johnny Depp, Mads Mikkelsen

Harry Potter is a multimedia franchise about an orphaned boy who enrolls at Hogwarts Faculty of Wizardry, the place he learns the reality about himself, his household, and the horrible evil that haunts the magical world. Tailored from the novels, Harry Potter is an eight-episode movie saga that follows the journey of Harry Potter and his mates, Hermoine Granger and Ron Weasley, as they navigate the difficult world of rising up, faculty life, and magic. Ranging from 12 months one and transferring to their seventh 12 months, the movies chronicle the scholars’ time at Hogwarts whereas unfurling a sinister plot that facilities across the unsuspecting Harry. With the return of the darkish wizard, Voldemort, the scholars and professors at Hogwarts will struggle to hold on because the world round them could change ceaselessly. Harry Potter has expanded past the world of its movies and novels with a number of video video games, a spin-off movie sequence titled Implausible Beasts, and even points of interest at Common Studios.