Analysis: Clinton foes, supporters feel vindicated by emails

Image: U.S. Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton speaks at the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute's 39th Annual Gala Dinner in Washington© Hillary Clinton speaks at the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute’s 39th Annual Gala Dinner in W… Image: U.S. Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton speaks at the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute’s 39th Annual Gala…

There’s something for everyone in the 12,073 released pages of John Podesta emails.

Now into its second week, Wikileaks’ daily releases of emails — allegedly stolen by Russian hackers from Hillary Clinton’s campaign chair personal account — are confirming what everyone thought they knew about Hillary Clinton.

For Donald Trump fans, they show the Democratic nominee is corrupt; for Bernie or Busters they show she’s beholden to Wall Street; for Clinton supporters, they show she’s as thoughtful and substantive in private as in public.

For everyone else, there’s an unprecedented look inside a powerful political network, with all its messy complexities and contradictions, thanks to what will likely become a seminal primary source for students of political campaigns for years to come.

Wikileaks is still sitting on over 50,000, which means they could keep dribbling them out at the current pace every day until Election Day and still have some left over.

If nothing else, the constant drip is a distraction — and the possibility of some explosive revelation yet to come will haunt the closing 22 days of the campaign.

But barring some major new revelation in yet-to-be released documents, few minds are likely to be changed. Instead, the emails essentially serve as political Rorschach test for how one felt about Clinton before reading them. It’s a textbook case of what psychologist call confirmation bias. Given a giant heap of evidence, people will naturally chose to consume only the pieces that reinforce their existing beliefs.

Clinton’s coziness with Wall Street was well known and her only crime in discussing the need for “private and a public position” during political negotiations was giving voice to what is universally true in politics.

That doesn’t mean the emails are valueless, nor that Clinton will be spared political repercussions; the daily releases are starting new fires that need to be dealt with.

Related: A Look at Hacked Emails From Clinton’s Campaign Chairman

But the intended audience of the exposure may not be voters alone, and may instead be the several thousand people doing the day-to-day work of trying to get Hillary Clinton elected in and around her campaign.

While some Wikileaks flare ups have played out in public, more have occurred out of sight among the professional Democrats whose private trash talk and gossip about each other has now been exposed.

Bernie Sanders and Bill Richardson have had to release public statements forgiving slights against them revealed in the emails, while countless private apologies have undoubtedly been meted out as well.

“The goal of this is to create dissension between everyone,” Center for American Progress President Neera Tanden, one of Podesta’s most frequent correspondents whose emails offer unusually candid criticism of Clinton, told Politico.

The newspaper reported, for instance, that Chelsea Clinton is “hurt” that Podesta didn’t defend her in a spat with Clintonworld frenemy Doug Band, and that morale is down at the campaign’s Brooklyn headquarters as some staffers pore over the releases.

Clinton has been here before, when she was secretary of state and Wikileaks released a trove of U.S. diplomatic cables.

“So out come hundreds of thousands of documents. And I have to go on an apology tour. And I had a jacket made like a rock star tour. The Clinton Apology Tour. I had to go and apologize to anybody who was in any way characterized in any of the cables in any way that might be considered less than flattering,” Clinton recalled in a private speech, whose transcript was ironically released by the latest Wikileaks dump.

Meanwhile, the emails, available to anyone, contain an immense amount of uncensored personal information that provides zero insight to the public. The inclusion of private information seems intended to purely damage these individuals, or at least will have that effect.

The archive contains intimate personal notes from Podesta’s wife and son wishing him a speedy recovery from surgery, sharing Thanksgiving travel plans, discussing recipes, thanking him for a birthday card, or just checking in. “Love and miss you,” Gabe Podesta, an Air Force officer, wrote in one email wishing his father a happy Fourth of July.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s