Friends’ Harshest Reality Was Less Forgivable From Its 84% RT Replacement Show

Friends’ alternative present, which has an 84% ranking on Rotten Tomatoes, in the end made its harshest actuality much less forgivable. The best episodes of Friends remind audiences why the hit sitcom is so sensible, which facilities on the six major characters’ wild escapades residing in New York Metropolis. Nevertheless, their existence create a sitcom plot gap that leaves us questioning their funds.

There are numerous financially unrealistic sitcom characters in TV historical past. In truth, the sitcom subgenre is well-renowned for this trope. As every season of Friends progresses, the characters’ funds solely make much less sense. Nevertheless, the characters in How I Met Your Mom are even worse on this context, and the present’s robust Rotten Tomatoes ranking isn’t sufficient to distract from it.

The Harshest Fact About Associates Is That Its Characters May By no means Afford Their Existence

The Careers Of The Associates Characters Aren’t As Properly Compensated As You’d Consider

For a bunch who steadily face a scarcity of labor, or are even fired at factors, the Friends characters are by no means actually that near dropping their properties. Associates depicts the monetary compensation of those characters’ jobs as being far safer than they’re, and this creates a number of plot holes.

Phoebe lives together with her grandmother for fairly some time, for instance, however for somebody who collects a pension and a masseuse, it is mindless that they’ll afford their place. Even later within the present, the one approach it’s logically potential for Phoebe to remain there may be if her roommate, Denise, pays for a majority of the hire and payments.

Associated

After Rewatching Friends, There’s Something Massive Missing From The Show That Really Bothers Me Now

Associates brilliantly depicts the realities of residing in New York Metropolis, however the hilarious sitcom is lacking one thing that continues to trouble me.

Monica’s condo is beneath hire management, however when she loses her job in season 2, Rachel continues to be solely a waitress. Even with hire management, earlier than Ross helps Monica, how can they afford their place? Joey’s appearing profession isn’t a safe type of employment, and paleontologists/college lecturers in the true world don’t reside the identical life-style as Ross, both.

In truth, Chandler is the one one out of the primary six whose paycheck is sensible. On the identical time, although, Chandler mainly pays for all the pieces Joey till he’s solid in Days of Our Lives, however after Drake falls down an elevator shaft, he’s again to sq. one. All through the present, the Associates gang are frivolous in terms of cash.

Rachel works laborious to avoid wasting for her Thanksgiving snowboarding journey, for instance, which ought to actually be a luxurious for a espresso store waitress. Curiously, the season 2 episode “The One With 5 Steaks and an Eggplant” acknowledges that Rachel, Joey, and Phoebe’s incomes differ vastly from the others. Nevertheless, after this episode, Associates doesn’t actually acknowledge the monetary divide.

How I Met Your Mom Repeated This Unbelievable Element From Associates

New York Is Costly, Regardless Of Which Sitcom You are In

How I Met Your Mother is considered Friends’ successor by many, however the different hit sitcom weirdly repeats this element. Like Chandler, the one character in How I Met Your Mom whose monetary state of affairs is sensible is Barney’s. It is because Barney’s job tasks are extremely obscure, however it’s established that he’s compensated properly and includes one thing secretive.

Nevertheless, every season of How I Met Your Mother takes issues even additional in terms of ludicrous bills, however particularly within the present’s earlier installments. Robin begins as a reporter for a small station hardly anybody watches, and he or she usually works unsociable hours, but she will afford a good condo by herself and a number of canines.

Lily is a kindergarten instructor, and it’s later revealed that she has a mountain of bank card debt. Earlier than she marries Marshall, Lily nonetheless has a small condo (which is ultimately was a Chinese language restaurant), however she’s all the time at Marshall and Ted’s place. Marshall is a regulation scholar, however we by no means hear any point out of a part-time job to maintain himself afloat.

Associated

It Took How I Met Your Mother 9 Seasons To Solve One Of The Sitcom’s Biggest Mysteries

Barney’s job at GNB was all the time saved a thriller regardless of what number of instances followers stated “please” – till season 9, that’s.

Regardless of the glamorous exterior of the job, architects don’t make as a lot cash as many consider. Ted is only 27 in How I Met Your Mother season 1, and most architects have a number of many years of expertise beneath their belts earlier than they lead any main tasks. Even when Ted had been some kind of younger architectural genius, he nonetheless couldn’t afford to help him, Lily, and Marshall.

It’s price noting that there are a number of particulars that assist justify this, even when they’re weak. For instance, within the How I Met Your Mother masterpiece episode “Slap Guess,” we find out about Robin’s previous as Canadian pop star Robin Sparkles, which suggests she doubtless has financial savings from her teenage years. Different episodes additionally set up that Robin’s father is a wealthy businessman, too.

How I Met Your Mom’s Outlook On Cash Is So Unrealistic

How I Met Your Mom one way or the other goes even additional with this than Associates, although. Whereas the actions of the Associates gang are unrealistic, How I Met Your Mom goes to the intense. Barney can one way or the other afford flights anyplace and in every single place, and Marshall is seemingly capable of drop his research or job on a whim, as are Robin and Ted.

Weirdly, Lily seems to be round a variety of the time. Though kindergarten takes up a very good quantity of the calendar yr, she’s current in most of How I Met Your Mother’s best episodes as a result of she’s by no means at work. The group is steadily up late, ingesting lengthy into the night time, however the subject of hangovers is just touched on a number of instances all through the present.

Even when their monetary conditions hit tough patches at factors, How I Met Your Mom rapidly forgets about it. For instance, Lily and Marshall don’t actually complain about their mortgage after they buy their first condo, regardless of its excessive rate of interest attributable to Lily’s bank card debt.

One other instance of this, particular to Lily, is when she returns to New York after breaking apart with Marshall. Lily notably struggles to search out her new calling in life and doesn’t have any safe employment, and whereas her tiny condo is falling aside, it is mindless that she will afford it by herself (even when it’s essentially the most practical one within the present).

How I Met Your Mom was on the air in the course of the 2008 monetary disaster, however the present didn’t actually reference this real-world occasion on the time, although it applied others into its tales. There are a number of obscure mentions of the Nice Recession, however it doesn’t seem to influence any of the characters the identical approach it did others, and if something, considerably trivializes it.

Associated

After Rewatching How I Met Your Mother In 2025, I Now Understand What Made It Better Than Friends

The Associates vs HIMYM debate might rage on eternally, however there’s one key distinction that proves which is the higher present.

Whereas Associates could also be one of the notable sitcoms that leans into the financially unrealistic character trope, How I Met Your Mom takes it additional than most titles. After all, not like Associates, How I Met Your Mom has an unreliable narrator, and it could make sense if Ted’s wacky tales exaggerate sure issues.