The unique Harry Potter motion pictures made one clear Hogwarts mistake, however the upcoming HBO reboot of the franchise can keep away from repeating the identical. Because the motion pictures virtually constantly did an unbelievable job of capturing the lore from the original Harry Potter books, they deserve credit score for preserving a lot of J.Okay. Rowling’s magical world.
On the similar time, although, one can not deny that the films, too, had their very own share of flaws and points that future variations can now repair. No e-book adaptation is ideal. Nonetheless, owing to their restricted runtime, the Harry Potter movies both needed to retcon a number of unique story beats or delete them altogether.
Since capturing the phrases from a fantasy novel within the live-action storytelling medium can all the time be difficult, HBO’s tackle the enduring books will seemingly not be free from storytelling issues. Nonetheless, it may nonetheless be taught quite a bit from every little thing that went mistaken with the films to ship a refreshing and extra trustworthy interpretation of Hogwarts and its key components.
The Sorting Hat Was an Integral A part of Hogwarts
With out It, The Faculty Would Not Have One Defining Custom
Initially belonging to Godric Gryffindor, one of many 4 founders of Hogwarts, the sorting hat is an important merchandise in Hogwarts’ traditions and historical past. Legends surrounding the hat reveal that it was enchanted by the mixed intelligence of all 4 founders: Salazar Slytherin, Rowena Ravenclaw, Gordic Gryffindor, and Helga Hufflepuff.
They created the hat to make sure that college students on the faculty have been sorted into 4 homes based mostly on the particular traits the founders needed to see in them. The hat additionally takes immense satisfaction in virtually all the time inserting college students in the home that greatest matches their personalities and potential. Within the motion pictures, nevertheless, the complete scope of the hat’s goal and intelligence stays barely unexplored.
The Harry Potter Films By no means Depicted the Sorting Hat Effectively Sufficient
There Is Extra To The Sorting Course of Than Meets The Eye
Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone appears to oversimplify the sorting ceremony by displaying how Harry convinces the hat to put him in Gryffindor although the hat inclines extra in the direction of placing him in Slytherin. This appears to promote the concept that the hat makes use of some type of Legilimency to learn a scholar’s ideas and weigh them towards its personal judgment earlier than asserting their home.
Whereas that is partially true, the books usually trace that the hat’s decision-making course of is way much less one-dimensional and likewise barely flawed. Within the books, a number of story beats spotlight how the hat determines the place a scholar belongs based mostly on persona traits, values, and ambitions. Nonetheless, if a scholar, like Harry, exhibits sufficient conviction, the hat adjustments its thoughts.
Dumbledore additionally appears to appreciate that characters, like Snape, have been locked into homes based mostly on early impressions and peer affect, which sealed their fates and led them down an alternate path.
There’s a sequence within the novels the place Dumbledore questions whether or not they kind the kids too younger as a result of he seemingly realizes that 11-year-olds are slightly too immature to appreciate their ethical inclinations and ambitions. He understands that although many college students persuade the hat to put them of their desired homes by displaying sufficient conviction, these wishes stem from restricted self-awareness.
Within the books, Dumbledore additionally appears to appreciate that characters, like Snape and Malfoy, have been locked into homes based mostly on early impressions and peer affect, which sealed their fates and led them down a darkish path. These contradictions not often emerge within the motion pictures, however the present can lastly deal with them.
HBO’s Harry Potter Present Can Lastly Repair the Sorting Hat Issues
The Present Has Sufficient Time To Spotlight The Complexities Of The Sorting Course of
In contrast to the films, the present should spotlight what Dumbledore thinks in regards to the sorting course of and all the problems it comes with. Just like the unique novels, HBO’s tackle Harry Potter also needs to reveal that Harry was not the one character who satisfied the hat to put him in his desired home.
Even Hermione, as she reveals in Order of the Phoenix, might have ended up in Ravenclaw if she had not proven sufficient dedication to be positioned in Gryffindor. If the Harry Potter present will get this proper, it should find yourself including extra emotional depth to Harry’s ultimate interplay together with his son, the place he assures him that it doesn’t matter which home he’s sorted into, so long as his coronary heart is in the correct place.
