Why So Many TV Shows Keep Trying & Failing To Repeat Game Of Thrones’ Best Episode

The “subsequent Game of Thrones” is a phrase that is been thrown round usually on the heels of HBO’s hit fantasy sequence, however networks appear simply as wanting to ship the following Purple Marriage ceremony. The Purple Marriage ceremony is likely one of the most memorable incidents in all of Recreation of Thrones. Certainly, Robb and Catelyn Stark’s deaths in “The Rains of Castamere” left viewers reeling lengthy after the credit rolled, setting the bar excessive for on-screen tragedies going ahead.

And with many shows trying to be the next Game of Thrones, it ought to come as no shock that many have tried to ship the identical shock and disappointment as “The Rains of Castamere.” Even HBO’s Home of the Dragon spinoff has its personal model of the Purple Marriage ceremony, although this installment factors to a harsh fact about these makes an attempt to copy the incident. Though it is sensible to need the identical stage of pleasure that the Purple Marriage ceremony generated, a lot of the efforts to match it are falling brief.

Each Present Desires To Have The Subsequent Purple Marriage ceremony After The Recreation Of Thrones Episode’s Success

Many Episodes Strive To Recapture Its Stunning Brutality

“The Rains of Castamere” is the highest-rated Recreation of Thrones episode on IMDb, and it is simply one of many present’s strongest installments. The truth that folks nonetheless speak about it, greater than a decade after the episode first aired, is a testomony to its success. And when different reveals’ main occasions are in comparison with the Purple Marriage ceremony, it is meant to indicate an identical stage of devastation and pleasure. It occurs surprisingly usually, with SlashFilm evaluating The Handmaid Story season 6’s wedding ceremony bloodbath to Recreation of Thrones, and Decider dubbing 1923‘s second-to-last installment its “personal Purple Marriage ceremony.”

Robb Stark (Richard Madden) looking serious in Game of Thrones

Associated

The Winds Of Winter Is Confirmed To Bring Back A Major Red Wedding Character & It Can Debunk A Robb Stark Theory About His Secret Child

A Robb Stark principle could be debunked by the return of a significant Purple Marriage ceremony character who’s already confirmed to look in The Winds of Winter.

Even Home of the Dragon wasn’t proof against this, as many puffed up season 2’s adaptation of Blood and Cheese because the franchise’s subsequent Purple Marriage ceremony. The Final of Us season 2’s main loss of life additionally sparked such comparisons; it appears to occur any time an enormous tragedy is anticipated. Nevertheless, only a few of those tv occasions actually elicit the huge response to Recreation of Thrones’ greatest episode. In truth, always referencing the HBO sequence whereas discussing different reveals’ massive incidents would possibly even be setting them up for failure.

The “Subsequent Purple Marriage ceremony” Comparisons Set A Lot Of TV Reveals Up For Failure

Recreation Of Thrones Units A Excessive Bar That Most Fall Quick Of

The Purple Marriage ceremony is a significant second in latest popular culture historical past, however evaluating each tv tragedy to the incident ensures that none of them stand out as particular. Typically, Recreation of Thrones turned such a phenomenon as a result of it was distinctive when it was airing. It was considered one of few fantasy reveals to achieve mainstream reputation and boast excessive manufacturing high quality. And its unflinching strategy to killing off main characters — one thing it could possibly thank George R.R. Martin’s books for — was barely much less frequent.

It feels unfair to match sure episodes to this one, because it units viewer expectations far too excessive.

Now, it looks like TV reveals are all making an attempt to outdo each other in the case of shock worth and brutality. This makes it extremely troublesome for any of them to depart a definite impression, which is one thing “The Rains of Castamere” by no means wanted to fret about. Moreover, Recreation of Thrones’ Purple Marriage ceremony unfolds on the peak of the sequence, with many different components contributing to its success. It feels unfair to match sure episodes to this one, because it units viewer expectations far too excessive.

Why It is So Arduous For Different Sequence To Replicate Recreation Of Thrones’ Greatest Tragedy

There’s Not Sufficient Construct-Up & They Do not Really feel Distinct Anymore

Robb And Catelyn Stark Standing Side By Side In Game Of Thrones Season 3

Past most new sequence not standing out as a lot as Recreation of Thrones, there are a pair different parts of the Purple Marriage ceremony which can be proving troublesome to recapture. For one, the emotional affect is far larger in “The Rains of Castamere” as a result of we have been given time to know these characters, and we have been led to consider they’re the sequence’ heroes. These with data of the books know what’s coming, however in any other case, Robb’s and Catelyn’s deaths really feel completely surprising and devastating.

In comparison with a sequence like The Final of Us, the place the largest loss of life solely builds on a single season of attending to know the character, it isn’t shocking the emotional punch is not as highly effective. Home of the Dragon additionally would not enable viewers to develop hooked up to Helaena or her youngsters earlier than delivering its Blood and Cheese scene. And reveals like The Handmaid’s Story could match the Purple Marriage ceremony when it comes to brutality, however the feeling of the incident is totally different, because the villains are those on the receiving finish of the violence.

Many of those reveals additionally do not have the identical large attain as Recreation of Thrones.

Many of those reveals additionally do not have the identical large attain as Recreation of Thrones. Because of this, even when their massive incidents do reside as much as the Purple Marriage ceremony, they’re much less prone to change into water cooler speak at work. “The Rains of Castamere” was fortunate as a result of it occurred at a time when Recreation of Thrones was blowing up and had given viewers loads of cause to be invested in its characters. Added to the sequence’ distinctive nature, these items set the Purple Marriage ceremony as much as be successful that is onerous to repeat.

Supply: IMDb, SlashFilm, Decider