While The Big Bang Theory has plenty of Halloween episodes in its 12-season run, not all of them were instant classics. Like any long-running show, The Big Bang Theory went through its ups and downs in terms of critical performance and fan reception. As a traditional multi-camera hang-out show featuring an ensemble cast, The Big Bang Theory was reliant on its lead characters for most of the show’s biggest laughs and could rarely fall back on experimental storytelling. However, that didn’t stop the celebrated series from following in the footsteps of so many other hit shows by offering rare, seasonal episodes.
Like other sitcoms of its kind, The Big Bang Theory would occasionally tell stories with Valentine’s Day, Christmas, and Thanksgiving themes that would break away from its usual formula. And of course, it took this approach with Halloween as well, bringing the spirit of the holiday into a stretch of episodes throughout the show’s run. In fact, the show found room for a total of four Halloween specials, spread throughout the show’s long tenure. Similar to its overall body of work, The Big Bang Theory’s Halloween episodes run the gamut from great to terrible.
4
The Good Guy Fluctuation
Season 5, Episode 7
Easily the show’s worst Halloween episode, The Big Bang Theory season 5, episode 7, “The Good Guy Fluctuation,” is particularly unpopular as this is the outing that saw Leonard cheat on Priya. While this Big Bang Theory Halloween episode was a betrayal of Leonard’s usually sweet character, that wasn’t the only issue with its plot. The show soon revealed that Priya had also cheated on Leonard, a twist that made their entire multi-episode romance seem pointless in retrospect. Like many of Leonard’s doomed romances, this storyline was played for laughs but ended up feeling surprisingly bleak despite this.
Since viewers effectively knew that Leonard and Penny would eventually end up together by the end of the series, many of The Big Bang Theory’s storylines surrounding Leonard’s love life were pretty half-hearted. Even so, this led to an issue that also arose in both How I Met Your Mother and Friends. Since viewers had no idea how long it would be until Leonard and Penny got together, as entire seasons of The Big Bang Theory were devoted to romances that were clearly going nowhere. Priya was a charismatic, funny addition to the show’s cast when she was first introduced, only for her role to be proven pointless in “The Good Guy Fluctuation.”
3
The Imitation Perturbation
Season 12, Episode 6
While The Big Bang Theory season 12, episode 6, “The Imitation Perturbation” is admittedly not an all-time great episode, this final season entry did feature some strong gags as Howard and Sheldon dressed as each other for Halloween. The simmering tension between Sheldon and Howard was always good for a few laughs as Howard usually took Sheldon’s constant mockery with good humor, but sometimes lashed out with hilarious pranks that drove his friend to unhinged breakdowns.
The strength of The Big Bang Theory’s cast proved pivotal to the appeal of “The Imitation Perturbation,” as seeing four of the show’s stars imitate each other was enough to carry the episode on its own. That said, “The Imitation Perturbation” was not without its problems. Leonard and Penny’s plot about remembering their first kiss very differently did not provide many laughs, but it also wasn’t moving enough to feel poignant.
In a season that gave the pair plenty of plot focus, this nostalgic trip down memory lane felt unearned when “The Imitation Perturbation” could have simply focused on Howard, Sheldon, Amy, and Bernadette. That said, it’s still one of the show’s better Halloween episodes thanks to the stellar work of The Big Bang Theory’s Jim Parsons, whose impersonation of Howard is an all-time great gag.
2
The Middle Earth Paradigm
Season 1, Episode 6
Speaking of Leonard and Penny’s first kiss, The Big Bang Theory season 1, episode 6, “The Middle Earth Paradigm” provided this classic moment in the show’s history. This episode places highly thanks to Leonard and Penny’s big scene, but it’s an otherwise standard season 1 outing with a lot of lazy jokes about Leonard, Sheldon, Howard, and Raj failing to fit in with Penny’s friends at her Halloween party.
Luckily, a few great gags elevate this episode, like Sheldon attending the party dressed as “The Doppler Effect” and struggling to see what’s so strange about his outfit. While it did take a while for The Big Bang Theory’s cast to gel well together, “The Middle Earth Paradigm” proves how much potential the show had. Leonard turning down Penny because she was drunk is a rare moment that has aged well from the early season, while his standing up to Kurt proved that the character has unlikely depths under his nervy exterior. While “The Middle Earth Paradigm” is imperfect, the episode still has both sweet and funny moments that make it one of the better outings from The Big Bang Theory season 1.
1
The Holographic Excitation
Season 6, Episode 5
While The Big Bang Theory season 6, episode 5, “The Holographic Excitation,” isn’t the show’s best outing, it is the strongest Halloween episode in the series. Not only does “The Holographic Excitation” feature a rare Howard-centric storyline, the episode also explores what draws Penny to Leonard. The Big Bang Theory’s Howard refusing to shut up about his recent space mission, along with him and Bernadette attending a Halloween party dressed as the Smurfs, is a classic bit. Meanwhile, Penny admitting that she finds Leonard’s scientific prowess hot explains a lot about their unlikely pairing.
For much of The Big Bang Theory’s early seasons, Penny’s attraction to Leonard is based entirely around him acting nice and, as such, their relationship seems more platonic than romantic. In “The Holographic Excitation,” viewers get another answer for how the duo ended up together, and it works almost as well as Sheldon and Amy’s comical arguments over couple costumes. Thus, “The Holographic Excitation” ends up firing on all cylinders as each of the show’s central couples gets a chance to shine. This helps make it The Big Bang Theory’s best Halloween episode.
What About Young Sheldon’s Halloween Episodes?
The Big Bang Theory spinoff Young Sheldon also focused a storyline or two on the spookiest holiday of the year, though it had much less prevalence. The Big Bang Theory already challenged conventional sitcom wisdom by not having an annual Halloween episode or including one in every season. Young Sheldon took this a step further, and there was only one Halloween episode in the entire show.
The only Young Sheldon Halloween episode came as the 6th of season 2 “Seven Deadly Sins and a Small Carl Sagan.” It definitely wasn’t the best in the series, and many viewers have pointed out that Sheldon taking a backseat in the episode missed an opportunity to lay down some of the foundations of the adult he became in The Big Bang Theory. Sheldon’s feelings about Halloween and costumes always make the TBBT Halloween episodes memorable, so it’s strange the prequel spinoff didn’t feature much of the October holiday.
The plot of the Young Sheldon Halloween episode also doesn’t rank among the show’s most noteworthy, whether it’s judged by hilarity or heartwarming wholesomeness. “Seven Deadly Sins and a Small Carl Sagan” spent more time on George’s attempts to flirt with Veronica, as well as a story about Mary’s community work, than it did on the Halloween celerations of Sheldon’s childhood. While they weren’t bad storylines, they’re far from fan-favorites.
While it’s safe to say that The Big Bang Theory handled Halloween better than Young Sheldon, it’s always worth noting that the two are different shows, especially when it comes to tone. Young Sheldon rarely aims for laugh-out-loud visuals like Howard and Bernadette dressed as Smurfs. The Big Bang Theory Halloween episodes may be better than the spinoff’s attempt, but that’s partly because TBBT went for laugh-out-loud spectacle-based comedy in ways that Young Sheldon didn’t.
- Release Date
-
2007 – 2019-00-00
- Showrunner
-
Mark Cendrowski
