Aanand L. Rai’s Tere Ishk Mein, starring Dhanush and Kriti Sanon recently released on OTT and has captured the attention of the internet, but perhaps not for the reasons the makers expected. While fans were happy to see the actor reunite with the Raanjhanaa director, a specific scene in the movie has triggered a massive debate among research scholars and the academic community on social media.
The controversy is based on a scene where Kriti’s character is seen holding a massive document, which is identified as a PhD thesis. In the scene, it is claimed that the thesis is of 2,200 pages. This detail did not sit well with the academic world, leading many PhD candidates and professors to call out what they describe as a highly unrealistic representation of doctoral research.
Social media platforms, particularly X, were flooded with reactions from scholars who pointed out that a standard PhD thesis typically ranges between 200 to 400 pages. Taking a dig at the creative liberty used in the film, one user commented, “2,200 pages? That’s not a thesis, that’s an entire library archive. No supervisor would ever agree to read that, and no binding would hold it together.”
The criticism comes from a desire for more authentic storytelling when it comes to professional lives. Scholars argued that while cinema often uses creative freedom to show intensity, such exaggerations make the struggles of real-life students look like a stereotype. Another researcher pointed out the logistical impossibility, saying, “A 2,200-page thesis is physically impossible to submit or defend. It shows a lack of basic research on how academia works.”
Despite the backlash regarding the thesis scene, Tere Ishk Mein managed a decent performance at the box office, if not massively successful. The film marked the third collaboration between Aanand L Rai and Dhanush, after their successful projects, Raanjhanaa and Atrangi Re.
Also Read: Box Office Report: Tere Ishk Mein Heads Toward The Rs 100 Crore Mark
